Skip to content
TRP

Workbook sheet

Evidence States

9 matching public rows · workbook v312-bcbfaf0393844f14e5d03119

References are navigational context only; they do not establish culpability or corroboration.

Row 3

  1. State
  2. Definition
  3. Permitted Use
  4. D848 Example
  5. Source
  6. Control

Row 4

  1. DOJ OFFICIAL REPRESENTATION
  2. Statement by DOJ about its own actions, counts, review process, production, or legal position.
  3. May report as DOJ said/reported; do not silently convert to independent fact.
  4. More than 500 reviewers; more than 6M pages potentially responsive; over 3M pages released that day.
  5. https://www.justice.gov/opa/media/1426091/dl
  6. ATTRIBUTION REQUIRED
Official source

Row 5

docket
  1. JUDICIAL CROSSWALK
  2. Later court opinion identifies a source/docket number or procedural fact.
  3. May use to map source identity/procedure; not to replace direct review of underlying source.
  4. Aug. 25 opinion cites Jan. 30 DAG Letter and Dkt. 848.
  5. https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/new-york/nysdce/1%3A2025cv10468/654959/10/
  6. MAPPING ONLY
Source link

Row 6

  1. DIRECT SOURCE VERIFIED
  2. Complete source accessed directly with page geometry confirmed.
  3. May award page credit subject to duplicate/privacy gates.
  4. Official DOJ PDF: 6 pages; all six visually checked.
  5. https://www.justice.gov/opa/media/1426091/dl
  6. PAGE CREDIT OK
Official source

Row 7

evidence
  1. SOURCE SELF-INCONSISTENCY
  2. Internal textual discrepancy preserved without silent correction.
  3. Report exact inconsistency; do not choose one side without evidence.
  4. Page 2 says “five primary sources” but enumerates six numbered source categories.
  5. https://www.justice.gov/opa/media/1426091/dl
  6. FLAG
Official source

Row 8

  1. QUALIFIED REVIEW CREDIT
  2. Pages reviewed with adequate source identity and privacy controls, but with stated provenance/continuity limits.
  3. Counts toward working page total once.
  4. 6 D848 pages credited; local binary/hash unavailable.
  5. https://www.justice.gov/opa/media/1426091/dl
  6. CREDITED
Official source

Row 9

clearlyevidence-used
  1. CONTINUITY-QUALIFIED CARRY-FORWARD
  2. State carried from latest completed report when exact predecessor binary unavailable.
  3. Preserve but clearly label; do not represent as newly re-proven.
  4. Counts 1,3,5,6 evidence-used states and prior 7,589 total.
  5. CAVEAT

Row 10

evidence
  1. UNKNOWN
  2. No sufficient evidence to determine.
  3. Do not infer.
  4. Jury reliance on any evidence remains unknown.
  5. FIREWALL